Skip to content

#SOL24-8 Brownies

It is Tuesday and time to write a 'Slice of Life." 
Thank you Two Writing Teachers for creating this supportive community
of teacher-writers!

FEELING COCKY

For years and years and years, I have baked homemade brownies, only homemade brownies, yummy homemade brownies. It’s really simple. I can be a little snooty about it, refusing to cook from a packaged mix.

I use the simple recipe on Baker’s Unsweetened Chocolate for ‘one bowl brownies.’ I always stir in a bag of chocolate chips as my final step before baking. (Is it possible to have too much chocolate? I don’t think so.) These are a crowd pleaser and I can basically make them with my eyes closed.

Be careful of what has become too ordinary for you. 

I set the oven, got out my bowl, and began to measure the ingredients. I got out a small second bowl to beat the eggs. I suppose Baker’s Chocolate Company would be disappointed in this second bowl, but one must put their own flourishes on recipes. Over the years, I have learned that I prefer to beat the eggs separately, rather than try to do so while combining them with the chocolate and sugar. 

Measure, mix, stir, yum. Everything is going well. I stir in the chocolate chips as the final step.

CONFUSION

Hmm. The mix looks a little different. Thicker. I can see the granules of sugar, and I don’t remember that being so before. I guess I haven’t made these in a long time. They’ll melt into yum in the oven, I reassure myself. 

Into the oven they go. I set the oven for thirty minutes and begin cleaning up the cooking mess.

Two minutes into their baking, I find the separate bowl of eggs. As in, sitting on the opposite end of the counter. As in, never stirred into the batter. Step 3!! Yikes! I rushed to the oven and took out the pan and prayed the brownies hadn’t cooked too much. Two minutes? That can’t be a big deal, right? 

I scraped the mixture into a third bowl. Bowl one was in the sink with soapy bubbles. Bowl two had the eggs. Oh my. 

I quickly mixed in the eggs – not at all easy to do, when flour and chips are in there, too. I’ve heard that you shouldn’t beat brownies too much…it makes them dry…ugh, there’s no escaping this now, I must beat in the eggs.

Done.

I popped them back into the oven, and set the timer for 25 minutes, so they wouldn’t overcook.

GOBSMACKED

I’m out of the room when the timer rings, so my dear husband turns it off. I jump over to the oven and speak to him with frustration – “Look! You turned off the OVEN, not just the timer! I may need to cook them longer.”

“I thought I hit the timer button not the on/off for the oven, sorry!” 

I open the oven door and it is cold. As in, no heat whatsoever. Brownies haven’t cooked at all. The oven hasn’t been on! What?!

I put the uncooked brownies on the counter, exasperated. I thought about my process . . .

CONTRITION

Oh my goodness. The mistake was TOTALLY MINE. Back when I rushed to the oven to grab the brownies and then mix in the eggs, that is when I myself must have turned off the oven. In haste.

(A quick temper will make a fool of you soon enough.)

I apologized to my husband for my snippy tone; it was not his mistake. 

I am beyond frustrated with these brownies, and with myself.. These ‘simple’ homemade brownies! My ‘go-to’ favorite! Oh my.

I turned the oven on. Waited for it to reheat. Popped the brownies back in. Again, I set the timer for 25 minutes. I double-checked that the oven was heated. I went back to my writing and waited for the timer to go off. 

In a matter of minutes, the room began to smell so heavenly. They were definitely cooking this time around.

EPILOGUE

Don’t they look delicious? 

No, they were an epic fail. 

Dry, crumbly, possibly overcooked. They were impossible to cut. 

One star for flavor.

Boo hoo. 

Served with ice cream, everyone was complimentary. But I knew better. (Still cocky, I guess.)

Simple recipes are meant to be simply followed. 

Published inpersonal narrativeSOLSC

18 Comments

  1. Terje Terje

    What a fabulous story of missteps. I love that as a seasoned baker you openly shared how things went wrong. Even if the brownies didn’t taste the way you had hoped for, the story was delicious.

  2. Oh my gosh, your lively writing drew me right in to this baking fail moment. Also, I can so relate to the homemade brownie commitment. I use the Katherine Hepbrun brownie recipe in Laurie Colwin’s More Home Cooking and I add a little cinnamon and it’s totally a crowd pleaser. Confession- I once did the very same thing you did with the eggs!

  3. Maureen,
    We’ve all been there. Especially those old enough to have been cooking and baking for many years. There are times i don’t want to follow the directions and look at the ingredients only. The. I create my own recipe in my head. You must bake a new pan of brownies ASAP to underpin your confidence. You can never have too much chocolate, right. Or ice cream, if you ask me. Also, you need a poem: One Star Review of Brownies. Check out the poem “One Star Review of the Great Wall of China” for a mentor text.

  4. Kim Johnson Kim Johnson

    Maureen, yet another reason we can be great friends. Brownie fails. I’m celebrating us this morning with the way we can be so quickly humbled right when we think we’ve got it. I’m crying with you for the brownie fail, and also about the fingerpointing on the oven (I would do that, too), and I’m laughing with you because in the normal moments of life, just in a simple one-bowl mix of brownies that has long been mastered as a trademark dish, we find ourselves human. And these are exactly the kinds of posts that keep me connected to my closest-feeling blog buddies. Time for a re-mix, my friend!

  5. Thanks for sharing. I like all the errors (rising action. conflict.)! The structure with the reflective comments and sub-headings were so thoughtful too.

    • Thank you! I was trying to find a way to keep the reader interested, lol. Sometimes, this point in the challenge, I tend to forego the longer reads – I thought section titles might help ease one into reading more.

  6. This is a great story that most of us can relate to! It was almost like the brownies began to spiral out of control when you broke the one bowl rule!

  7. Ah, you tricked me with the Epilogue title and photo of the brownies. I thought it was going to be some surprising alchemy that happened in the oven and made them taste good! There is something my husband and I often manage to do when turning off the timer on our electric stove–and that is push cancel with the annoying beep. No, that would be the oven heat we just canceled!! It reminded me of that when Tony said, “I thought I hit the timer button not the on/off for the oven, sorry!”

    I’m glad you were able to salvage the brownies after the myriad brownie fiascos. Ice cream can cover a lot of sins!

  8. I loved this! Who hasn’t had a cooking mishap? I have never made brownies, but I do make blondes now and then. I stir in some M&Ms as the final step. Sometimes the simplest things go awry. That’s just life.

  9. Oh, I hate what I do stuff like that–from leaving out ingredients to turning the oven off. I have done both of those! I love your last line! Yes, it does!

  10. This happened to me at Christmas when I went to take out the dressing to take to my daughter’s home. I had accidentally turned off the oven. We took it to daughter’s house and baked it there. It was a second course halfway into the meal!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *